Home » Content Moderation’s $9B Industry Faces Supreme Court Test

Moody v. NetChoice: Supreme Court Shielded Content Moderation in 2024 Ruling

By

–

Content Moderations 9B Industry Faces Supreme Court Test

The decision landed on the first Monday of July 2024, and it read like a dismissal letter to two state legislatures. Content moderation, the Supreme Court held in Moody v. NetChoice, is itself speech. When Florida and Texas tried to dictate what platforms must carry, the majority said, the states ran headlong into the First Amendment.

The laws at the center were Florida’s Senate Bill 7072 and Texas’s House Bill 20. Both, as the case archive kept by EPIC lays out, regulated how and when platforms could moderate: limits on banning or shadowbanning users, transparency duties, notice before removals, and a Florida requirement that companies let users swap algorithmic feeds for a purely reverse-chronological one.

Justice Elena Kagan wrote for the court, and she began by conceding the states’ point before refuting it. “States (and their citizens) are of course right to want an expressive realm in which the public has access to a wide range of views,” she wrote. “But the way the First Amendment achieves that goal is by preventing the government from ‘tilt[ing] public debate in a preferred direction,’ not by licensing the government to stop private actors from speaking as they wish and preferring some views over others.”

The ruling was not a final verdict, though. Kagan sent the case back for a closer look at what the laws would actually cover, and the definitions, she warned, ran wide. Florida drew its line at platforms with 100 million monthly users, or annual revenue of $100 million; Texas at 50 million. Left standing, such laws could reach “how an email provider like Gmail filters incoming messages, how an online marketplace like Etsy displays customer reviews,” or how a payment service and a ride-sharing app run themselves.

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who had spent years likening platform moderation to unconstitutional censorship, did not take it quietly. “I will keep fighting for our law that protects Texans’ voice. No American should be silenced by Big Tech oligarchs,” he wrote on X, calling the issue one of the biggest threats to free public discourse and election integrity.

Where the case goes next is largely the Fifth Circuit, whose earlier rulings helped push it to the Supreme Court in the first place and where six judges were appointed by Donald Trump. Corbin Barthold of TechFreedom predicted “there is going to be a lot of maneuvering” as lower courts reexamine the laws against other kinds of services.

The substance of the opinion leaned one direction all the same. Eric Segall, a constitutional scholar at Georgia State’s law school, read it flatly: “The court is very clear you can’t regulate this way,” he told CyberScoop. Kagan herself wrote that a Texas-style law would be unlikely to survive First Amendment review, because it stops a platform from “compiling the third-party speech it wants in the way it wants” and offering the product that reflects its own priorities.

Industry and civic groups split the win. Linda Moore of the trade group TechNet warned that stripping the protections would have made the user experience less safe and weakened U.S. innovation. Nora Benavidez of Free Press, pointing to platforms that had deprioritized moderation and slashed trust and safety teams before the 2024 elections, aimed hers at the top of the industry: “Today’s ruling should send a message to the likes of Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk: Your commitment to platform integrity is protected under the First Amendment,” she said.

Sources

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

US News

Courts & Law

Immigration

US Travel & Outdoors