A window air conditioner is not made of steel. Under the Trump administration’s revised metals tariffs, it is taxed as if it were. That gap is where the Lawfare analysis published in April 2026 sees the best chance of a court fight over Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962.
The administration announced the changes earlier that month. They cover steel, aluminum and copper, and a new set of tariffs on certain pharmaceutical imports. Both rest on Section 232, which lets the president “adjust the imports” of an article if a Commerce Department investigation finds that imports of it “threaten to impair the national security.” That is a different legal footing from the “IEEPA tariffs” imposed last year on most trading partners, which the Supreme Court ruled unlawful in late February.
Courts have gone along so far
Judges have been deferential to Section 232 since the Supreme Court upheld its use for tariffs in a 1976 case, Federal Energy Administration v. Algonquin SNG. Challenges to the first-term steel and aluminum tariffs never reached the Supreme Court. The Federal Circuit took a deferential view of them, and in 2023 upheld the president’s power to change the tariffs to cover more products outside the original timeline in the statute. By contrast, last year’s reciprocal tariffs drew multiple lawsuits that ended up at the Supreme Court, and the Court of International Trade recently heard arguments in two suits against the fallback reciprocal tariffs. Significant challenges to the Section 232 actions in Trump’s second term have been comparatively few.
Three tiers for metals
The Commerce Department opened Section 232 investigations into steel and aluminum imports in 2017. In 2018 it found that imports of both metals impaired national security, and the president imposed 25 percent tariffs on steel and 10 percent on aluminum. In 2020 Trump extended them to “derivative” articles, then made up almost entirely of metal, such as nails and car bumpers. Last year he raised the steel and aluminum rate to 50 percent, announcing it at a rally in western Pennsylvania, and began sweeping in products with only a little metal in them. Canned beer was tariffed as an aluminum derivative, though importers paid the 50 percent rate only on the value of the can. Copper joined in August 2025.
The new system has three tiers. Raw steel, aluminum and copper, and products essentially made entirely of them, such as copper or steel pipe and steel nails, face 50 percent. Derivative products with substantial metal content that are not obviously metal goods face 25 percent. Products made abroad with U.S.-origin metal pay 10 percent, and goods from the U.K. made with U.K. metal get lower rates under a deal struck last year.
The 25 percent now applies to the full value of the import. The 2025 scheme taxed only the metal content. Importers no longer have to calculate metal value, but many will pay more. Gas stoves, air conditioners and heaters are among the goods taxed on their full value as steel derivatives. A product is exempt only if the importer shows it contains less than 15 percent of a tariffed metal by weight.
What counts as a derivative
Section 232 never defines the word. It only authorizes tariffs on “the article and its derivatives.” Earlier cases did not settle the question, since the products in the 2023 Federal Circuit decision included metal nails and fasteners, and the plaintiffs did not dispute that they were derivatives.
The analysis argues that this is now open to attack. After the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Loper Bright v. Raimondo, which overturned Chevron deference, courts need not give the government’s reading special weight. A plain reading of “derivative” suggests something derived from another thing, not something that merely contains it. A 1960 Webster’s defines it as “anything obtained or deduced from another.” A steel nail fits that. An air conditioner, the analysis says, does not.
The legislative history is thin. Congress added the derivatives language to the predecessor statute in 1958, and Senate hearings that year suggest senators mostly had oil in mind. They wanted a president who limited crude imports to be able to limit refined products too. In 1959 President Eisenhower imposed quantitative limits on crude oil and various oil products.
One possible standard would require a derivative to contain a large share of the underlying material, perhaps 50 percent or more. In his first term Trump stipulated that steel and aluminum had to make up at least two-thirds of a derivative’s materials value. This year’s threshold is 15 percent. Under a 50 percent test the president could still order a Commerce investigation into air conditioner imports. He could not tariff a product just because it contains some metal.
Drug tariffs built for deal-making
The pharmaceutical tariffs use the same legal basis but a different design. Commerce began its investigation last April. The administration has not released the full findings, but the proclamation noted that more than half of U.S. drugs still under patent are made outside the country and that 85 percent of the ingredients for those drugs are made abroad. A study last year found 700 medicines with at least one ingredient sourced solely from China.
Trump mostly exempted generics, though the U.S. depends on China and India for many of them, and aimed the tariffs at on-patent medicines. The baseline is 100 percent. Drugs from the European Union, Japan, South Korea and Switzerland, which signed trade deals last year, face 15 percent. Companies that have signed deals with Commerce to move production to the United States and agreed to so-called MFN pricing can import drugs tariff free through Jan. 20, 2029. The analysis says the structure appears meant to serve goals beyond national security, including keeping costs low for U.S. consumers.





