Home » Securities fraud lead plaintiff process explained under federal law

Securities fraud lead plaintiff process explained under federal law

By

–

Securities fraud lead plaintiff process explained under federal law

Before 1995, a shareholder could file a securities fraud suit with thin evidence and hope that pretrial discovery would turn up something better. Defending those cases cost so much that companies often settled rather than fight, even when the charges were unfounded. Congress changed the rules that year with the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, known as the PSLRA.

One of its biggest changes put the investor, not the law firm, in charge of the case.

Who leads the case

When several shareholders sue over the same alleged fraud, the PSLRA requires the court to merge the actions into one lawsuit. A plaintiff or group of plaintiffs is then appointed to lead it. Usually more than one investor asks for the job.

The statute presumes the “most adequate plaintiff” is the person or group with the largest financial interest, who also meets Rule 23’s typicality and adequacy requirements. In practice that means the greatest sustained loss. Courts at this stage look for only a preliminary showing, and the fuller examination waits for class certification.

Congress wanted large holders, whose interests line up with those of ordinary shareholders, to keep counsel in check. A big stake gives an investor a reason to watch the lawyers. Retirement funds and other institutions often take the role, though individuals can too. Pension funds, family offices and single investors can all qualify.

What the lead plaintiff does

The lead plaintiff picks and retains lead counsel, subject to court approval. It monitors the attorneys, takes part in major decisions including settlement talks, and speaks for class members who are absent. It does not do the legal work itself.

The presumption can be challenged. A rival must show the front-runner will not fairly protect the class or faces unique defenses. Courts ask for actual proof, not speculation. Only potential class members may be heard on the question, and defendants generally have no standing to oppose an appointment.

Timing is tight. After a complaint is filed and notice is published, investors generally have 60 days to move for appointment.

Sitting out is an option. Class members who are not appointed generally still share in any settlement or judgment. Leading the case simply gives an investor direct control over it.

The pleading bar

The PSLRA also made suits harder to start. A complaint must identify each statement alleged to be misleading and explain why. It must also state facts giving rise to a “strong inference” that the defendant acted with the required state of mind, known as scienter.

The Supreme Court took up that phrase in a June 21, 2007 opinion by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. The inference must be “cogent,” the Court held, and “at least as compelling as any opposing inference of nonfraudulent intent.”

The stakes of the motion to dismiss are large. If a case survives it and the court certifies a class, the defendant faces enormous exposure and heavy pressure to settle. Plaintiff lawyers argue for lower pleading standards. Defense lawyers argue the opposite, saying looser rules invite frivolous suits and extorted settlements that mostly benefit lawyers.

Scholars have also noted problems with the lead plaintiff system, including hesitance among some institutional investors to serve and past allegations of “pay-to-play” arrangements. Research discussed in legal scholarship links institutional lead plaintiffs to larger settlements, though results depend on the facts of each case.

Sources

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

US News

Courts & Law

Immigration

US Travel & Outdoors