In 2008, White respondents to a large national survey were the most conservative group and Black respondents the most liberal. By 2024 that gap had shrunk sharply. The gap between college graduates and everyone else had grown.
That is the finding of a new paper in PNAS Nexus by political scientist Stephen Jessee, titled “Americans’ ideological differences have decreased by race, increased by education.”
What the survey covered
Jessee used the Cooperative Election Study, which ran in each of the five presidential election years from 2008 to 2024. Across those waves it gathered answers from more than 250,000 people: 32,800 in 2008, 54,435 in 2012, 64,600 in 2016, 61,000 in 2020 and 60,000 in 2024.
Respondents gave their race and education level. Their ideology was scored from 132 policy questions on subjects such as taxes, abortion, immigration, health care and the environment, then placed on a liberal-conservative scale.
Race gap closes, education gap opens
The racial gap closed mainly because Black and Hispanic respondents became more conservative on average. Jessee’s co-authored conclusion put it this way: Americans’ ideologies “have become more similar across races, driven primarily by Blacks moving sharply to the right, but also by Hispanics becoming slightly more conservative.”
Education moved the other way. In 2008, graduates already leaned the most liberal and people with less schooling leaned more conservative. By 2024, respondents with a high school diploma or less, and those with some college, had grown more conservative. Those with college and graduate degrees had grown more liberal.
The split peaked in 2020, when the two degree-holding groups swung sharply left of where they had been in 2016. Then 2024 brought a shift toward conservatism at every education level. College and graduate respondents landed about where they had been in 2016. Those with a high school education or less moved further right still.
The education pattern showed up within every racial group. It was steepest among White Americans.
How it fits earlier work
Other researchers have found that education divides partisan vote margins only among White voters, not among minorities. The study authors say their results differ. In their words, the findings show that “American politics have realigned not just in terms of previously documented partisan vote shares but also in terms of policy-based ideological positions.”
For context, Gallup’s 2025 averages put 35% of Americans at conservative, 33% at moderate and 28% at liberal.
The paper carries a caveat. Ideology responds to current events and to how opinion leaders frame their positions at a given moment, so past trends may not predict future ones.





