A pharmacy technician at Ascension Saint Thomas Midtown in Nashville filled syringes with potassium phosphate and labeled them mepivacaine, an anesthetic. Surveillance video reviewed by state investigators shows it. Four joint replacement patients got the wrong drug on Aug. 14.
The Tennessee Health Facilities Commission has now made public an 80-page report on the incident. Seven patients were having surgery while the error was in play, and four of them received the wrong medication. According to the report, they suffered “unexpected and progressive neurological, respiratory, and hemodynamic decline.”
How the check failed
Investigators found that the pharmacy’s system let technicians override barcode scanning and type in medication details by hand. One technician involved had been flagged for performance and training concerns the day before; the probationary period had been extended and the technician was getting extra coaching. In an interview, the technician said they had never prepared mepivacaine before and conceded not looking at the vial during part of the verification.
The pharmacist’s final check missed it too.
Regulators classified three areas as “Immediate Jeopardy,” meaning the problems had caused or could cause serious harm or death. Ascension submitted plans to fix them during the investigation, and investigators found those plans unacceptable at the time. The findings had not been cleared when the survey ended on Aug. 21, which does not necessarily mean they still stand. The report spoke of a “culture of overall noncompliance.”
The response afterward
The report faults what happened once patients began to deteriorate. The hospital did not immediately take everyone directly involved off clinical duty, and the anesthesiologist was not placed on administrative leave. Investigators also cited problems with peer review and with pharmacy staff training, and WSMV reported that pharmacy workers were not retrained after the incident.
One of the four patients is Glenda Dorton, 72. Her family told FOX 17 News she went in on Aug. 14 for a routine knee replacement and woke unable to feel or move anything from the sternum down. She was later told she has T-6 paralysis.
Logan Grant, the commission’s executive director, told FOX 17 News the redacted report is public and has been shared with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has confirmed it is investigating.
What Ascension says
Ascension has apologized to the patients and families. It says its review found no other patients were affected, and that hospital leadership reported the error to regulators itself. New safeguards include separating and clearly marking high-alert medications, extra verification when a spinal medication triggers a scanning alert, and a second trained pharmacist for final checks on spinal medications.
In a statement, the hospital said it has seen “some inaccurate interpretations” of the report in the media and that it takes the findings “extremely seriously.” It added that it is “continuing to cooperate with state and federal surveyors.”
Sources
- State finds multiple safety failures after Ascension Saint Thomas medication mix-up
- State report cites failures at Ascension St. Thomas Midtown after 4 patients given wrong medication during surgery
Sources
- State finds multiple safety failures after Ascension Saint Thomas…
- State report cites failures at Ascension St. Thomas Midtown after…





