Home » Fitzpatrick Faces Toughest Challenge Yet in PA District Race

Fitzpatrick Faces Toughest Challenge Yet in PA District Race

By

–

Brian Fitzpatrick

“Brian Fitzpatrick is Brian Fitzpatrick. I’m not Donald Trump. I’m not anybody else.” That is how the Bucks County Republican told CNBC he wants voters to see him, in a year when his party’s label is a burden almost everywhere.

Fitzpatrick is seeking a sixth term in Pennsylvania’s 1st Congressional District, a swing seat that chose Joe Biden in 2020 and Kamala Harris in 2024. For most of his career Democrats have failed to dislodge him. His challenger this time, Democrat Bob Harvie, is a Bucks County commissioner and former teacher, and CNBC reported in late October that the race had turned competitive ahead of the November 3 election.

A moderate, tested

Fitzpatrick is a former FBI agent who succeeded his brother Michael in Congress in 2017. He co-chairs the bipartisan Problem Solvers Caucus. According to a Philadelphia Inquirer analysis of his voting record, he has voted against the White House and his party more than any other House Republican this Congress. He is critical of the president too: “I’m not happy with his tone,” he told CNBC.

Harvie says that independence is oversold. He calls Fitzpatrick a rubber stamp and points to votes. Fitzpatrick was one of only two Republicans to vote against the final version of the party’s 2025 tax and spending package, but he voted for an earlier version, saying he opposed the Medicaid cuts added in the Senate. Harvie also cites his record on tariffs and his vote for the SAVE America Act.

The campaign has also been ugly. WHYY described the contest as very combative. Fitzpatrick’s campaign and a super PAC have attacked Harvie over a federal investigation into possible corruption in the Pennsbury School District. Harvie says he only testified as a witness before a federal grand jury, calls the attacks a baseless smear and has sued the PAC for defamation. Fitzpatrick declined WHYY’s repeated invitations to appear on its program.

Polls and money

Independent polling is thin. An internal survey for Harvie by Global Strategy Group showed a tie. A September poll for the National Republican Congressional Committee and Fitzpatrick’s campaign had the incumbent ahead by nine points. A New York Times, Philadelphia Inquirer and Siena University poll found Harvie leading 48% to 46%, inside the margin of error.

The Cook Political Report moved the race from “Likely R” to “Lean R” in October. Its House analyst Erin Covey called Fitzpatrick Democrats’ “white whale.” Fitzpatrick points out that he won nearly 55% in the district in 2022, the same year Josh Shapiro took 59%, which he sees as proof of ticket-splitting.

Spending tells its own story, according to AdImpact data cited by CNBC. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee has committed more than $1.5 million to TV ads since the start of October, and House Democrats’ main super PAC more than $7.5 million. Neither had bought ads there since 2020. On the Republican side, the Congressional Leadership Fund has committed just under $5 million and the NRCC just over $1 million. An October 12 FEC filing showed MAGA Inc. buying $100,000 in ads against Harvie. As of October 14, Fitzpatrick had more than $709,000 in cash, to just over $409,000 for Harvie.

Harvie remains a long shot, CNBC reported, and Fitzpatrick is still favored.

Sources

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

US News

Courts & Law

Immigration

US Travel & Outdoors