In April, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signed a law barring any local government in the state from spending money on diversity, equity and inclusion programs. LGBTQ+ advocates call it a “pride ban,” because it could threaten nondiscrimination ordinances, local pride events and other services.
The law’s definition of DEI comes from a model bill written by the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, according to a report by Uncloseted Media that Ms. Magazine republished. The institute is a New York City-based, conservative-leaning think tank formed in 1978. Since it released the model bill in 2023, at least 10 states have introduced anti-DEI bills with nearly identical language. The report also says the institute helped inform the Trump administration’s policy on gender-affirming care through its work on the Department of Health and Human Services’ pediatric gender dysphoria report.
None of this was a priority before the 2020s. The institute, best known for championing Reaganomics, was not focused on LGBTQ+ issues. That changed.
A think tank with Wall Street money
For nearly 50 years the institute has shaped conservative policy by drafting model legislation and publishing reports for lawmakers and lobbyists. Its longtime causes include libertarian economic policy, discrediting teachers unions and deregulating healthcare. Conservatives on Wall Street fund it, and its latest tax filings show over $30 million in net assets.
It began publishing City Journal in 1990. Robert Asen, a communications professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, says the magazine, which reports over 350,000 monthly online visitors, is a big part of the institute’s reach. “There’s the power of promotion that the Manhattan Institute provides: They are well-resourced in lots of ways,” he told Uncloseted Media.
Paul Singer, founder of the hedge fund Elliott Management, became chairman of the board of trustees in 2008. Bloomberg later reported he wanted the institute to become a “Wall Street equivalent of the Federalist Society.” Singer first opposed Donald Trump, then warmed to him after the 2016 election earned his firm over $42 million through a jump in private prison stocks. “He was a very strong opponent and now he’s a very strong ally,” Trump said of him at a 2017 press conference. Former Attorney General William Barr and former Education Secretary Betsy DeVos from Trump’s first administration later joined the institute’s board.
Turning against “wokeness”
Asen dates the change to 2020. After the murder of George Floyd by Minneapolis police officers, many organizations changed how they handled racism, often under the banner of DEI. Social conservatives pushed back hard. Asen says the institute fused that anger with existing anti-LGBTQ+ sentiment and went all in on “anti-wokeness.”
Christopher Rufo, then a contributing editor at City Journal, wrote pieces headlined “Teaching Hate” and “Against Wokeness,” then went on Tucker Carlson’s show to urge Trump to end racial sensitivity trainings for federal employees. Days later Trump signed an executive order doing that. The institute hired Rufo as a senior fellow in 2021, and in 2023 it released the model legislation he wrote to ban DEI at public universities.
Language from the bill appeared, often word for word, in bills in Florida, Texas, Iowa, Mississippi, Missouri, South Carolina, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Arizona. Sociologist David J. Luke of the University of Michigan-Flint says that framing distorts what the programs are for. They are “really designed to try to make things more fair,” he said.
The campaign has been most successful in Florida. Documents obtained by American Oversight show DeSantis’ office communicated directly with Rufo, and DeSantis appointed him to the board of trustees of the New College of Florida in 2023. Rufo wrote in City Journal that 36 left-wing faculty members resigned in the first few months of his leadership.
Teachers unions and gender-affirming care
Joanna Wuest, a political scientist at Stony Brook University, says the focus on schools serves a larger goal. “The Manhattan Institute and other libertarians are extremely opposed to labor unions,” she said, and going after public education as a bastion of “woke indoctrination” is a way of going after teachers unions.
In 2022 the institute also began positioning itself against gender-affirming care. Billionaire Joseph Edelman, founder of Perceptive Advisors, gave it $500,000 over the next two years for a “gender identity initiative,” whose mission the institute has not publicly described. It hired political scientist Leor Sapir that year and later brought on evolutionary biologist Colin Wright. The two lead what the institute calls its “global effort to end pediatric sex-trait modifications.”
Quinnehtukqut McLamore, an assistant professor of psychology at the University of Missouri, explains why the tactic works. “Attacking LGBTQ+ rights is an effective strategy because bluntly, people don’t like gay people and don’t like trans people,” he said.
Sources
Sources
- How the Manhattan Institute Turned Anti-LGBTQ+ Politics Into …
- Boroughs of New York City – Wikipedia





