Home » Supreme Court Ruling In Curtiss-Wright Case Affirms Presidential Authority Over Foreign Af

Supreme Court Ruling In Curtiss-Wright Case Affirms Presidential Authority Over Foreign Af

By

–

Supreme Court Ruling In Curtiss-Wright Case Affirms Presidential Authority Over Foreign Af

Curtiss-Wright Export Corp. was charged with conspiring to sell aircraft machine guns to Bolivia. That was an ordinary criminal case. The defence it chose made it a constitutional one, and the Supreme Court’s answer in 1936 still gets quoted whenever a president acts abroad without asking Congress first.

An embargo on the Chaco War

The Chaco War broke out between Paraguay and Bolivia in June 1932. Both countries were poor and leaned on outside military help, which interested American arms makers. Washington wanted no part of it. Antiwar feeling at home, revulsion at how the war was being fought, and pressure from the United Kingdom and the League of Nations all pushed the government to shut the trade down.

On May 24, 1934, Congress passed a joint resolution. If the President found that banning arms sales to the countries fighting in the Chaco “may contribute to the establishment of peace,” he could proclaim an embargo. Violators faced a fine, prison, or both. Franklin Roosevelt signed the resolution that day and issued a proclamation starting the embargo. He revoked it on November 14, 1935.

The challenge

By then Curtiss-Wright had been indicted. Its lawyers demurred, arguing that Congress had handed legislative power to the executive without limits, giving the President “unfettered discretion” over a decision that belonged to Congress. The lower court agreed. The government took the case to the Supreme Court.

The company raised three questions. Did the resolution violate the non-delegation doctrine? Did due process require the President to make findings of fact behind the proclamation? And did revoking the proclamation wipe out the penalty for breaking it?

The Court ruled 7-1 for the government, in an opinion by Justice George Sutherland. He split the federal government’s powers in two. The rule that Washington may use only powers listed in the Constitution, plus those needed to carry them out, is “categorically true only in respect of our internal affairs,” he wrote. Foreign and domestic powers are “different, both in respect of their origin and their nature.”

The Constitution never says the President holds all of foreign policy. Sutherland reasoned that the power comes with the office anyway, since the executive of a sovereign nation is built to conduct foreign affairs. The President, he wrote, has “the better opportunity of knowing the conditions which prevail in foreign countries.” He has “his confidential sources of information” and agents in the diplomatic and consular services. The Court found “sufficient warrant” for the discretion Congress gave Roosevelt to judge whether the ban would help restore peace.

Sutherland also described the President as “the sole organ of the federal government in the field of international relations,” holding a power that needs no act of Congress behind it.

What came after

Executive supremacy in national security became one argument for the nearly successful push in the 1950s to add the Bricker Amendment to the Constitution. Most fights between the branches are political questions the courts decline to hear, so Sutherland’s sweeping language is regularly cited for claims that a president may act abroad without congressional approval.

The Court itself has never gone that far. In Federal Energy Administration v. Algonquin SNG (1976) it upheld presidential limits on oil imports, resting on broad language Congress had used to delegate authority. In Zivotofsky v. Kerry (2015) it said Curtiss-Wright was wrong to call presidential power over foreign relations “plenary and exclusive.” Curtiss-Wright, the Court wrote, “does not support a broader definition of the Executive’s power over foreign relations that would permit the President alone to determine the whole content of the Nation’s foreign policy.” The Executive, it added, “is not free from the ordinary controls and checks of Congress merely because foreign affairs are at issue.”

Curtis Bradley and Jack Goldsmith, in a 2023 paper, called the decision “the foundational decision in support of a foreign affairs exception to the nondelegation doctrine.”

Sources

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

US News

Courts & Law

Immigration

US Travel & Outdoors