The question came at a town hall in Caro, Michigan, over the weekend, from a man in the audience. “Will you disavow the Muslim Brotherhood?” he asked Democratic Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed. A simple question, the man insisted.
El-Sayed said “Sure. Yeah, absolutely,” then turned it around. Why was he asking? Told only that the Brotherhood was “a terrorist group”, El-Sayed supplied the answer himself. “You’re asking the question because implicitly you assume that I’ll have dual loyalties,” he said. Responding to the same question, he also said he is “running for Senate and happens to be Muslim.”
A Familiar Line of Attack
Throughout the campaign, Republicans including President Donald Trump and nominee Mike Rogers have tried to tie El-Sayed, the son of Egyptian immigrants, to Islamic extremism. Most recently they have pointed to old social media posts from his half-sister about their mother, who left El-Sayed in early childhood and was active in the organization in the 1970s. Asked about the posts by NBC’s Tom Llamas, El-Sayed called them hearsay and said he has no ties to the group. “You want to ask me about what was happening in Egypt in 1970? Are you serious?” he said.
Bridge Michigan analysed the claims in September and found no direct evidence for Rogers’ assertion that El-Sayed had “pledged his support to the Muslim Brotherhood”. Trump has meanwhile repeatedly called El-Sayed “Mohammed” and a “jihadist”.
Todd Green, a religion scholar, says the wording matters. Muslims asked about terrorism are usually told to “condemn” it, which presumes collective guilt by association. “Disavow” goes further, said philosopher of language Grace Paterson, because it implies a significant connection between person and thing. A plain yes would concede that charge. Saher Selod of the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding called it a campaign strategy to link him to groups the US deems terrorist. Green noted that El-Sayed “very adeptly, quickly turned the question back on the questioner.”
Who He Is
El-Sayed was born on October 31, 1984, in Rochester Hills, Michigan. His father, Mohamed, came from Alexandria, Egypt, to study at Wayne State University. His mother, Fatten El-Komy, is a nurse practitioner. His parents divorced when he was three, and his father and stepmother raised him around Detroit. He graduated from Bloomfield Hills Andover High School in 2003 as captain of the wrestling, football and lacrosse teams, then took a biology and political science degree at the University of Michigan in 2007.
A Rhodes Scholar, he earned a doctorate in public health at Oxford, then a medical degree at Columbia in 2014, where he became an assistant professor of epidemiology. He never completed residency training and is not licensed to practice, and Rogers and other critics call his use of the word physician misleading. In August 2015 Mayor Mike Duggan appointed him head of the Detroit Health Department, at 30 the youngest health officer in a major US city at the time. He ran Wayne County’s health department from 2023 until April 2025, when he resigned to run for the Senate. He lost the 2018 governor’s primary to Gretchen Whitmer.
The Race
A progressive, El-Sayed backs Medicare for All, ending US military funding to Israel and abolishing ICE. He beat Rep. Haley Stevens in the August primary, 48.4 percent to 47.6 percent. If elected on November 3, he would be the first Muslim and first Egyptian-American in the US Senate.
At the second and final debate, hosted by WXYZ Detroit, each candidate accused the other of lying. Rogers cited a “pattern of deception”; El-Sayed dismissed this as “MAGA Bingo”. On the Brotherhood, El-Sayed told Rogers that questioning his commitment to the Constitution was “beneath you”. This weekend, former President Barack Obama rallies in Detroit and Trump in St. Clair County. El-Sayed will join Obama. Outside groups had spent a combined $95 million to boost Rogers and $42 million for El-Sayed, in what is already the most expensive election in Michigan history.
Sources
- Abdul El-Sayed
- Fact check: Abdul El-Sayed, Mike Rogers debate trade, money, immigration, more – Bridge Michigan
- What Republicans mean when they ask Abdul El-Sayed to ‘disavow’ the Muslim Brotherhood | CNN
Photo: U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (Public domain)





