Home » Americans Oppose ICE Tactics By Two-To-One As Public Sentiment Shifts

Americans Oppose ICE Tactics By Two-To-One As Public Sentiment Shifts

By

–

Americans Oppose ICE Tactics By Two-To-One As Public Sentiment Shifts

Fifty-six percent of Americans now hold an unfavorable view of Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Just 35 percent see it favorably and 9 percent are unsure, according to a Pew Research Center survey of 5,062 adults conducted from September 28 to October 4. Of the 12 federal agencies Pew asked about, ICE ranks last. An ABC News poll reported that Americans oppose the tactics ICE uses to enforce immigration law by a margin of two to one.

Party and Race

Both parties have soured on the agency over the past year, though the gap between them stays wide. Two-thirds of Republicans and Republican-leaning independents still view ICE favorably, down from 72 percent a year ago. Among Democrats and Democratic leaners, 84 percent are now unfavorable, up from 78 percent.

Majorities of Black adults (69 percent), Hispanic adults (67 percent) and Asian adults (66 percent) hold a negative opinion, and in each group the numbers are substantially worse than last year. White adults are the least negative, but even they have crossed over: 49 percent are unfavorable, up from 45 percent in 2025, while 42 percent are favorable, down from 48 percent. Among Republicans, 71 percent of White respondents view ICE favorably, against 53 percent of Hispanic Republicans, a small group in the sample (201 people, margin of error about 10 points).

Among Democrats, roughly nine in ten White respondents (89 percent) are negative, compared with 82 percent of Asian, 79 percent of Hispanic and 75 percent of Black Democrats.

Bigger, Louder, Closer

The agency is far more visible than a year ago. The Department of Homeland Security says ICE hired 12,000 new officers and agents last year. Arrests have more than doubled in 15 states and the District of Columbia this year, and many sheriffs now partner with ICE under the 287(g) program to carry out federal immigration functions.

Politics has kept pace. Republicans and allied groups spent $53 million on immigration ads in 27 states from January to June. “Soft on crime” has become a lead attack line, and President Donald Trump has invoked the notorious 1988 Willie Horton ad at a campaign rally.

An Echo of the Tough-on-Crime Years

A new study of elected prosecutors in the Journal of Public Economics shows what such rhetoric can do. Looking at nearly 40 states from 1986 to 2006, the author found state prison admissions rose 3 percent in years when district attorneys faced election, which works out to 63,000 additional admissions. Crime and arrest rates did not rise in those years. The effect was strongest in the South and in Republican counties, and it faded after about 1994, when public appetite for harsher courts softened.

The two eras differ. Tough-on-crime policies enjoyed near consensus and often bipartisan backing, and tough-on-immigration policies do not. In February, 50 percent of Americans supported deporting all immigrants lacking permanent legal status and 48 percent opposed it. Yet 62 percent opposed ICE tactics, and approval of the president’s handling of immigration had fallen 10 points in a year.

Mixed Signals Before the Midterms

On one side stand protests and local opposition in blue states. On the other is $70 billion in Republican-backed congressional funding for ICE and the Border Patrol. With midterms next week, control of Congress and the direction of immigration enforcement are both on the ballot. Last year, Pennsylvania voters ousted a Republican sheriff in favor of a Democrat who ran on ending the local partnership with ICE.

Sources

Photo: usicegov (Public domain)

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

US News

Courts & Law

Immigration

US Travel & Outdoors