WASHINGTON, November 21, 2026 — A draft inspector general report obtained by The New York Times details what one ICE instructor called a “catastrophic failure” in training standards, revealing that nearly 6,000 officers received reduced instruction during a hiring surge between August 2025 and July 2026. The 19-page draft from the Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Inspector General describes a cascade of shortcuts, including virtual academies completed in hours and the removal of testing limits, that the watchdog says the agency has not fully repaired.
The Scale of the Reductions
The draft report, dated Nov. 20 and described by the Times, covers a period when ICE expanded rapidly under former Secretary Kristi Noem. More than 3,500 recruits with prior law enforcement backgrounds were allowed to complete basic training online rather than attend a monthlong in-person program. More than 80 percent finished the virtual coursework within 10 days, over 10 percent in under 24 hours, and at least five officers in roughly two hours.
For the more than 2,000 recruits without police experience, the residential academy was cut from 72 days to 42 and from 543 instructional hours to roughly 300. The draft says the reductions touched firearms, arrest procedures, driving and the ability to determine citizenship status. A rule limiting trainees to two attempts on proficiency tests was also dropped; one officer reportedly took a test 32 times before passing.
Field Training Judged a Failure
The watchdog found that the abbreviated classroom work was compounded by failures in the field. Nearly 90 percent of ICE officials who managed on-the-job training and responded to the inspector general’s questionnaire said the program was not successful. One instructor told investigators the revised training amounted to a “catastrophic failure,” a phrase the draft report highlights as emblematic of the internal alarm.
The draft attributes the pressure for speed to former Secretary Noem and adviser Corey Lewandowski, noting that ICE’s former training chief told investigators he was ordered to carry out the reductions. The figures align with reporting from The Washington Post in March, which documented a 40 percent cut in instructional hours using internal ICE outlines.
Restoration and Remaining Gaps
Secretary Markwayne Mullin, who succeeded Noem, restored stricter requirements in July 2026. At a House Homeland Security Committee hearing on Nov. 18, Mullin said officers who had not completed full background checks or the full 13-week training had been placed on administrative leave. He acknowledged that some decisions made before his tenure were ones “we are having to undo.”
However, the draft report states that despite the increased hours for future recruits, “ICE has not fully addressed training gaps born of the reductions and revisions.” The watchdog’s findings, if they survive in the final version, would contradict DHS claims from February that a compressed six-day schedule preserved instructional quality.
Litigation and Oversight Implications
The draft report carries weight beyond the academy. Attorneys challenging warrantless arrests and use-of-force incidents, including a class action in Virginia, may seek training records to argue that officers were unprepared to apply legal standards. Congressional committees pressing for data on officers sidelined for incomplete training would gain a baseline for reporting requirements if the final report includes recommendations.
The central unresolved question is whether ICE will retrain the roughly 6,000 officers who cycled through the shortened programs or apply the restored standards only to new hires. The draft remains subject to agency comment before publication, and ICE’s formal response, along with any recommendations and the agency’s agreement or dissent, is not yet public.
Sources
- ICE Training Cuts: Draft Watchdog Report Faults Officer Academy
- 'Catastrophic failure' unearthed in watchdog probe of embattled agency: NYT
Photo: usicegov (Public domain)





